The American dream is damaged. The best hometowns for raising a family could offer solutions

Most of the threads of family life within the U.S. really feel like they’re fraying. Discovering the correct faculty is a time-consuming slog. Expert medical doctors and specialists have monthslong wait lists. The quest for getting older assist programs appears inconceivable to navigate.

Managing any one among these challenges could be a lot to deal with, however members of the “sandwich era”—folks of their late thirties, forties, and fifties—try to do all of it, juggling the wants of each their rising youngsters and older mother and father.

Almost half of Individuals who’re raising kids underneath the age of 18 are additionally shouldering the accountability of usually caring for their getting older mother and father in some capability, in line with a survey performed by The Harris Ballot on behalf of Fortune in August.

But the place you reside could make all of the distinction to managing these caregiver roles. Effectively-being is not a pleased accident however as an alternative the results of a mixture of behaviors and social circumstances that form Individuals’ lives, says Michael Rickles, vice chairman of analysis at Sharecare.

In an evaluation of almost 2,000 cities and cities throughout the U.S., Fortune discovered that communities within the Midwest, West, and mid-Atlantic had been extra prone to offer higher entry to high quality hospitals and medical doctors, strong public faculties, and assist for older residents, than within the Southeast and at extra inexpensive charges than in main metros like New York and San Francisco.

“Simply since you need to reside in a sure space doesn’t imply it may give you what you want,” says Susann Crawford, who heads Caring.com’s referral companies. She routinely sees conditions through which households are evaluating the price of companies the place their mother and father reside versus the place they or their siblings reside— after which deciding to maneuver to wherever has the best combine of excellent faculties, entry to well being care, and getting older assist. The U.S. Postal Service processed 36 million change-of-address requests in 2021, up from the 29 million handle updates filed in 2020.

It’s not stunning that many Individuals took the chance to maneuver when distant work exploded throughout the pandemic. It gave them a once-in-a-lifetime alternative to search out neighborhoods providing a higher mixture of facilities that promote well-being and work-life stability. Folks moved to cities inside driving distance of main cities—shut sufficient to all of the perks of a cultural and financial hub, however extra inexpensive and with stronger group ties, in line with a CBRE Group evaluation. 

Being ‘sandwiched’ takes a toll

Kim Hamiter, 45, is conversant in the struggles going through the sandwich era dynamic. A divorced mother of two, she’s raising daughters in Columbus whereas concurrently caring for her mom, who has dementia. But even after transferring in together with her mom final yr to offer extra hands-on supervision, Hamiter says the scenario is difficult. “I’m so exhausted,” she admits. “I don’t know what I might do with out my ladies and my sister serving to me. As a result of generally, I can let you know, I do go into the bathe and I cry.”

But Hamiter’s duties could be extra burdensome if she lived someplace with even fewer sources. She was capable of finding and rent a residence well being aide who helps out together with her mom 5 hours a day, 5 days a week. Hamiter’s job with the State Supreme Courtroom is additionally nonetheless permitting employees to usually work at home, flexibility that routinely proves essential. “You positively want that assist out of your job,” she says. 

Hamiter isn’t alone in feeling exhausted. Most of the older millennials and Gen Xers who make up the sandwich era are additionally holding down full-time jobs. It’s tough to handle so many competing duties: work, youngsters, mother and father.

The majority (62%) of the sandwich era say they really feel like they’ve to decide on between being a good guardian and being a good son or daughter, in line with a latest survey by residence well being care companies firm Residence As an alternative. Greater than six in 10 report they usually run errands, present transportation, monitor well being situations, and cook dinner and clear for their mother and father.

All of that is made a lot more durable when group sources are scarce.

But that’s the truth for so many Individuals who reside in locations that lack entry to high quality well being care or good faculties or senior dwelling choices. College budgets have been slashed throughout the pandemic, and plenty of are going through trainer shortages. Libraries and group facilities have in the reduction of their choices, some even shuttering.

The many wants and competing priorities going through the sandwich era impressed the inaugural Fortune 25 Best Locations to Reside for Households. In our evaluation we thought-about schooling high quality, getting older sources, common wellness elements, affordability, livability points resembling crime charges, and variety.

The successful metropolis, Ann Arbor, is a midsize group that is residence to top-ranked College of Michigan, and its instructional prowess extends throughout the spectrum with the overwhelming majority of the district’s Ok-12 faculties rating above common. The proximity to the college additionally delivers a large wellness profit, with the College of Michigan’s well being system and educational medical heart incomes prime marks for affected person security since 2012—one among solely 23 U.S. hospitals to take action.

Establishing roots in a livable group is essential, as many discover themselves making private {and professional} sacrifices to handle the burden of care. Almost half (48%) of these within the sandwich era have used trip days to do caregiving duties, in line with the Residence As an alternative survey. About 27% of those that are employed have turned down promotions or alternatives for skilled growth, whereas 17% stated they needed to give up their jobs. About one in 5 switched from full-time to part-time positions.

No marvel so many employees are refusing to hand over the newfound WFH flexibility with out a struggle—indicating the migration might proceed. Getty finds 29% of employees who say they’re able to working remotely are nonetheless working from residence full-time, whereas 49% of employers function underneath some form of hybrid scenario. Lower than a quarter of those that are capable of work at home are in an workplace full-time. Whereas headlines blame Gen Z for the return-to-office riot, sandwich era members arguably profit most from the change.

“An getting older senior is simply as unpredictable of their wants as an toddler or toddler. You possibly can’t plan once they get sick,” says Caring.com’s Crawford.

The variety of Individuals who discover themselves within the sandwich era will probably improve within the coming years, particularly as millennials begin to enter this stage of life. Seven in 10 Individuals with a minimum of one dwelling guardian say they anticipate to assist their getting older mother and father usually sooner or later, Fortune’s survey discovered. That sentiment jumps to 88% amongst millennials.

There are companies and sources that may assist, from hiring a residence well being aide to establishing transportation and even meals supply companies that may present wholesome meals for all the family. And the standard, affordability, and availability of those companies depend upon the place you reside.

“You’re not alone. You’re not the one one which feels this manner. You’re not the primary one to have these challenges,” Crawford says.

Enroll for the Fortune Options electronic mail listing so that you don’t miss our largest options, unique interviews, and investigations.